Iridesce Sent
 

 
Twists and Turns of Phrase ::

iridesce at gmail dot com ::
 
 
 
About Me



Subscribe to My Site Feeds:
FeedBurner


Know; Correspond With; Love:
Something More Than a Machine

Know; Correspond With; Like:
I Am Tetsu Maiku!

Foxxtail

Frenetic License

Knock-Off Brand Root Beer Can

Penultima Thule

Dan Stutzbach

Welcome Consumer

Don't Know; Correspond With; Like:
The Dayree of Pritcher Littlebarn

James and the Blue Cat

Not Falling Down

Something Requisitely Witty and Urbane

Don't Know; Don't Correspond With; Like:
Defective Yeti

Dooce

Extended Cake Mix

Kottke

Mighty Girl

Mimi Smartypants

Oblivio

Que Sera Sera

This Afternoon in Drama

Geekery:
Astronomy Picture of the Day

Boing Boing

Engadget

Futurismic

Gizmodo

Neural

Popgadget

Slashdot

Wired News

Art and Design:
Apartment Therapy

Design Sponge

Funfurde

MoCo Loco

Sensory Impact

Shopping:
Amazon

Elsewares

Mark & Larry's Stuff

Mighty Goods

Wishing Fish

 
 
Friday, May 28, 2004
 
::NOT-SO-RANDOM QUOTE::

"If Mozart had patented the symphony, what would Beethoven have done?"
— A software exec decries looming European legislation that would grant broad patents on code.

(via Wired News)
Comments:
WWBD!
 

WWBD? He'd hack, I think.

(NOTE: "WWBD" is much better than "WWMD," because aside from not making any sense with the quote, it has very political harmonics.)
 

If Mozart had patented the symphony then Beethoven would have kicked Mozart's ass in the Best Piano Concerto Competition™.

And then Stravinsky would have come along decades later and created the classical music version of Napster.
 

I'm just guessing here, but I believe he would pay royalties to the patent holder. Not that I'm defending software patents, but a symphony patent wouldn't have necessarily stopped symphony writing, it would merely have required the payment of royalties to the patent holder. Also since Mozart wrote his first Symphony in 1772, the patent would have expired before Beethoven wrote his first in 1800. This really isn't a very good argument against software patents.
 

Post a Comment

 

 
   
  This page is powered by Blogger, the easy way to update your web site.
www.flickr.com
This is a Flickr badge showing public photos from Iridesce. Make your own badge here.
 

Home  |  Archives  
Site Meter